Should Olympic Golf Be Contested By Professionals Or Amateurs?
The Golf Monthly team debate whether the Olympics has got it right in reserving golf for the world's best professionals
![Shane Lowry and Rory McIlroy pose on a tee box with the Olympic rings in the background](https://cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.net/KGrbG9hwsgyYrLEZZZjsfi-415-80.jpg)
Ever since golf was added back into the Olympics in 2016, questions have been raised over its format, whether it should be doubles, mixed or even contested by amateurs.
The amateur question was raised after a number of top pros withdrew from Rio 2016, with some believing that elite professional golf already has enough meaningful and historic titles to play for.
One pro with that belief is former World No.1 and 2013 Masters champion Adam Scott, who has withdrawn from consideration from all three Olympics that golf has featured.
“People watch us play 45 weeks a year,” Scott once said. “If you really wanted to grow the game you’d have the Olympics for amateurs.”
The amateurs could use the Olympics to springboard their careers into the professional game or to top US colleges - but it appears that there is now no going back and golf in the Games is reserved for the sports' elite in the paid ranks.
So is that the right format for golf in the Olympics? The Golf Monthly team discuss...
Without question, Olympic golf should be a professional event. The Olympics is all about the pinnacle of sport and having the likes of Rory McIlroy, Scottie Scheffler and Jon Rahm compete is a must for both the Olympics and golf.
Get the Golf Monthly Newsletter
Subscribe to the Golf Monthly newsletter to stay up to date with all the latest tour news, equipment news, reviews, head-to-heads and buyer’s guides from our team of experienced experts.
Coming once every four years, it shouldn't be seen as a springboard to future success. Instead, a gold medal should be something every golfer aspires to winning, no matter how many Green Jackets or Claret Jugs they own.
Perhaps it isn't quite at that level yet but let's not forget that golf only returned to the Olympics in 2016. There's a place for it at the pinnacle of the professional game.
In my mind, Olympic golf should be professional only. I understand the arguments for amateur inclusion, but if your goal is to grow the game and increase participation, you need to put your best assets from and centre.
Some professional golfers will be recognisable to those who tune in, even if they're not golf fans, and the pros have the potential to hit heights that amateurs cannot reach.
I think the format seriously needs looking at – there's a clear opportunity to do something different and more engaging – but I'm not an advocate of having amateurs in the field.
I was always in two minds about whether golf should feature amateurs or professionals, but for women’s golf in particular, when we are continually trying to generate greater female interest in the sport, this is another opportunity to showcase the leading female tour players on a global stage.
You could argue that elite amateur golfers would be more relatable to any young women tuning in, but in my opinion it’s always good to aspire to be the best in your chosen sport!
The reason the authorities were so keen to have golf return to the Olympics after a 100+ year absence was to grow the game and take it to a new audience. Therefore to show it off in its most favourable light it seems clear to me that the best professional players in the world need to be involved.
While I don’t agree with the current format and think that the Olympics is perfect for a mixed competition, I do believe the cream of the crop need to be competing to showcase the sport and bring new people in.
The old amateur ideals of the games are long gone and it would have been a mistake for golf not to bring its biggest stars to the party.
Originally I did think that it should have been amateurs. Boxing has a good system where the Olympics is one of the peak amateur achievements so you get a real sense of who the brightest prospects will be when they turn pro. That would have worked in golf, with the Olympics carrying similar weight to the US and British Amateur Championships, perhaps?
However, now we're three Olympics in for professional golf, I think it works. The players are buying into it more and more, and I think the move to introduce mixed doubles in the Olympics golf event for 2028 will be a great thing.
Had players continued to skip it like we saw in both Rio and Tokyo, it would have lost credibility. But the fact that both men's and women's World No.1s are playing as well as the likes of Xander Schauffele and Rory McIlroy, it's going to continue to grow.
I can certainly understand some points in favor of the opposite, but my view is that the Olympics should remain as a professional event for golf. If an amateur qualifies via their world ranking, they should - of course - be allowed to compete, but it makes more sense from an entertainment and commercial sense to watch the very best players on the planet in a unique setting.
Plus, with the Olympic ideals being about excellence - alongside respect and friendship - even the World No.378 pro could challenge the World No.1 if the stars align while the chances of that happening in the amateur game is likely to be even smaller.
I can see arguments for both. When you look at the likes of amateur boxing, the peak of it is a gold medal at the Olympics.
However, the whole point of golf being included is to grow the game and if it didn't have the biggest names in the world present, then, let's be honest, people are less likely to tune in.
If sports like darts and snooker were put into the Olympics, and you didn't have Michael Van Gerwen or Ronnie O'Sullivan appearing, would as many people watch? I don't think so.
The last Olympics showed that anything is possible, even when it's only the pros that are involved.
Rory Sabbatini and C.T Pan were ranked well outside the world's top 100 yet still secured medals, which sort of sums up the Olympics... the underdogs performing for their country.
The Olympics should definitely be professional golfers. If you want to enthuse and capture non-golf fans through the olympics, as many sports do, you have to expose them to some of the best in the game.
While the sentiment around amateurs qualifying for the olympics is a nice thought, I don't see how that helps the longevity of participation and interest in the sport.
Elliott Heath is our News Editor and has been with Golf Monthly since early 2016 after graduating with a degree in Sports Journalism. He manages the Golf Monthly news team as well as our large Facebook, Twitter and Instagram pages. He covered the 2022 Masters from Augusta National as well as five Open Championships on-site including the 150th at St Andrews. His first Open was in 2017 at Royal Birkdale, when he walked inside the ropes with Jordan Spieth during the Texan's memorable Claret Jug triumph. He has played 35 of our Top 100 golf courses, with his favourites being both Sunningdales, Woodhall Spa, Western Gailes, Old Head and Turnberry. He has been obsessed with the sport since the age of 8 and currently plays off of a six handicap. His golfing highlights are making albatross on the 9th hole on the Hotchkin Course at Woodhall Spa, shooting an under-par round, playing in the Aramco Team Series on the Ladies European Tour and making his one and only hole-in-one at the age of 15 - a long time ago now!
Elliott is currently playing:
Driver: Titleist TSR4
3 wood: Titleist TSi2
Hybrids: Titleist 816 H1
Irons: Mizuno MP5 5-PW
Wedges: Cleveland RTX ZipCore 50, 54, 58
Putter: Odyssey White Hot OG #5
Ball: Srixon Z Star XV
-
How Many Birdies Scottie Scheffler Has Made In 2024
Scottie Scheffler has had an incredible year he has largely dominated throughout, but how many birdies has the World No.1 achieved?
By Mike Hall Published
-
Omega European Masters Tee Times: Round Four
Matt Wallace leads the way at the Omega European Masters as he looks for his fifth DP World Tour win
By Mike Hall Published
-
Curtis Cup Stars Sara Byrne And Mimi Rhodes Turn Pro
The Great Britain & Ireland teammates have announced that they have left their amateur careers behind
By Mike Hall Published
-
Junior Solheim Cup Teams 2024: USA And Europe Line-Ups
The 13th edition of the Junior Solheim Cup takes place at Army Navy Country Club in Arlington, Virginia - here are the teams
By Mike Hall Published
-
Solheim Cup Tee Times And Full Schedule 2024
Discover when each session of the 2024 Solheim Cup is taking place at Robert Trent Jones Golf Club
By Jonny Leighfield Published
-
'At The Very Least, The FedEx Cup Playoffs Need A Re-Think'
Is it time for the FedEx Cup finale to look at alternative formats, or does the staggered start work? We discuss...
By Elliott Heath Published
-
GB & I Win Curtis Cup For First Time Since 2016 In Thrilling Climax: As It Happened
GB & I defeated Team USA 10.5 - 9.5 at Sunningdale in a fascinating Sunday finish that swung both ways before the hosts finally sealed the deal
By Jonny Leighfield Last updated
-
Curtis Cup Tee Times: Sunday Singles
A thrilling finish is in prospect at Sunningdale with the Sunday singles as Great Britain and the US compete for the Curtis Cup
By Mike Hall Published
-
Big Names Spotted Supporting Great Britain & Ireland Curtis Cup Team At Sunningdale
Charley Hull and Justin Rose are among the high-profile players who have been offering their support to the hosts as it takes on the US in the biennial match
By Mike Hall Published
-
Dunning Golf Reveals Team USA's Solheim Cup Uniforms
Dunning Golf has brought patriotism to life through the uniforms of the US Solheim Cup team
By Alison Root Published