'It Is Surely Vital That The LIV Ban Is Resolved For Next Time'
Jeremy Ellwood discusses whether the Presidents Cup should be scrapped after 12 US wins from 14 editions
The Presidents Cup returns for its 15th edition this year after 12 US wins, one International triumph 26 years ago and a solitary tie in 2023.
There have been calls for the Presidents Cup to be mixed or even scrapped completely due to the USA's dominance.
So should it be scrapped? Jeremy Ellwood discusses...
Why would anyone even suggest such a drastic course of action?
Why would anyone even suggest such a drastic course of action?
It may sound harsh, but since the inaugural event in 1994, the International team has managed just one victory and one tie while the American team has won 12 times, including nine straight from 2005.
It is 26 years since the International team’s solitary success in 1998 at Royal Melbourne under the captaincy of the late Peter Thomson.
Have any of those many International defeats been close or not?
Yes. After a convincing American victory in 1994, the 1996 staging was close, with the International team winning Saturday’s matches 7-3 to trail by just one heading into the singles. However, they couldn’t quite get it done on Sunday, losing 16.5-15.5 overall.
Get the Golf Monthly Newsletter
Subscribe to the Golf Monthly newsletter to stay up to date with all the latest tour news, equipment news, reviews, head-to-heads and buyer’s guides from our team of experienced experts.
Since then, however, there have been several one-sided affairs and a couple of routs, with just 2003’s tie and the 2015 and 2019 contests being closer than a two-point difference.
Doesn’t that suggest the tide may be turning in the Presidents Cup?
Possibly, but the margins of defeat in the 2017 and 2022 events have still been eight and five points respectively.
The Ryder Cup followed a similar path for many years and look where that is now...
True. From 1927 to 1977 you could argue that the level of American Ryder Cup dominance makes the Presidents Cup look nip and tuck – 22 victories, one tie and just three losses. There have now been 22 matches since Europe came on board in 1979 and the figures since then are nine wins to America, 12 to Europe and one tie.
But this came about because there was a further source of players to draw from as new stars from continental Europe had arrived on the scene. When your team is already effectively the rest of the world, there is nowhere else to turn.
Why has the International team struggled so much?
It’s hard to say as they are all great players. You could argue that trying to get players from different countries to gel is a harder task than with 12 players from one country, but that hasn’t stopped the European team from succeeding in the Ryder Cup.
The American teams have invariably held a significant world ranking superiority and that, ultimately, appears to be just too much to overcome. However, again, that hasn’t stopped European Ryder Cup teams that are often weaker on paper from defying the odds.
This year, a ban on LIV players will also leave Mike Weir’s International team below full strength, with the likes of Cam Smith, Louis Oosthuizen and Joaquin Niemann ineligible.
Does it matter that the Presidents Cup is so one-sided?
You could argue that fans still get to watch lots of top-quality match-play golf, and that’s a good thing. But if the result becomes too predictable, interest can wane.
Assuming the Cup won’t be scrapped, it is surely vital that the LIV ban is resolved for next time so the International team can field its 12 strongest players.
Jeremy Ellwood has worked in the golf industry since 1993 and for Golf Monthly since 2002 when he started out as equipment editor. He is now a freelance journalist writing mainly for Golf Monthly. He is an expert on the Rules of Golf having qualified through an R&A course to become a golf referee. He is a senior panelist for Golf Monthly's Top 100 UK & Ireland Course Rankings and has played all of the Top 100 plus 91 of the Next 100, making him well-qualified when it comes to assessing and comparing our premier golf courses. He has now played 1,000 golf courses worldwide in 35 countries, from the humblest of nine-holers in the Scottish Highlands to the very grandest of international golf resorts. He reached the 1,000 mark on his 60th birthday in October 2023 on Vale do Lobo's Ocean course. Put him on a links course anywhere and he will be blissfully content.
Jezz can be contacted via Twitter - @JezzEllwoodGolf
Jeremy is currently playing...
Driver: Ping G425 LST 10.5˚ (draw setting), Mitsubishi Tensei AV Orange 55 S shaft
3 wood: Srixon ZX, EvenFlow Riptide 6.0 S 50g shaft
Hybrid: Ping G425 17˚, Mitsubishi Tensei CK Pro Orange 80 S shaft
Irons 3- to 8-iron: Ping i525, True Temper Dynamic Gold 105 R300 shafts
Irons 9-iron and PW: Honma TWorld TW747Vx, Nippon NS Pro regular shaft
Wedges: Ping Glide 4.0 50˚ and 54˚, 12˚ bounce, True Temper Dynamic Gold 105 R300 shafts
Putter: Kramski HPP 325
Ball: Any premium ball I can find in a charity shop or similar (or out on the course!)
- Elliott HeathNews Editor
-
Which Presidents Cup Team Is More Affected By Lack Of LIV Golfers?
LIV Golfers are not allowed to compete in the Presidents Cup due to their PGA Tour suspensions
By Elliott Heath Published
-
Relegated Player Fires Lowest Round Of The Day Whilst Brooks Koepka Shoots 80 At LIV Golf Team Championship Finale
Branden Grace shot the lowest round in Dallas on Sunday, whilst five-time Major winner Brooks Koepka, surprisingly, carded the worst round of the day
By Matt Cradock Published
-
Which Presidents Cup Team Is More Affected By Lack Of LIV Golfers?
LIV Golfers are not allowed to compete in the Presidents Cup due to their PGA Tour suspensions
By Elliott Heath Published
-
Tiger Woods' Presidents Cup Vs Ryder Cup Stats Show Some Jaw-Dropping Differences
There are remarkable stats that illustrate just how different Tiger Woods played in the Presidents Cup compared to the Ryder Cup
By Paul Higham Published
-
Presidents Cup Schedule, Tee Times And TV Coverage Details
All you need to know about the biennial tournament between Team USA and the International Team ahead of their clash in Canada
By Paul Higham Published
-
What Would A Mixed Presidents Cup Look Like?
We look at the format, qualification and team line-ups for a proposed mixed Presidents Cup event involving the best male and female players from the USA and International teams
By Paul Higham Published
-
'I Want To Prove That I'm Still A Great Player' - LIV Golfer Cameron Smith Sets Sights On More Major Titles
The 2022 Open champion has told Golf Monthly he still has plenty to prove in the game, and more success in the Majors is one of the ways he can achieve it
By Mike Hall Published
-
'It's Kind Of Nice To Be Able To Come Out To An Event And Wear Something That No One Else Is Wearing' - Jason Day Exclusive On His Malbon Golf Apparel That Got The Golf World Talking In 2024
The Australian has spoken about his clothing deal with the company known for its unconventional styles
By Mike Hall Published
-
Big Names Missing The Presidents Cup
Who are the notable players to miss out on the US and International teams for the 2024 Presidents Cup?
By Elliott Heath Published
-
Justin Thomas Reacts To Missing First US Team In Eight Years After Presidents Cup Omission
In a lengthy social media post, Thomas said he was "very bummed" to miss out on the Presidents Cup while also announcing he is set to become a father in November
By Elliott Heath Published