‘Asterisk Majors’ - LIV Golf Commentator Says ‘Political Stronghold Over The World Rankings’ Must Come To An End If Best Fields Are To Compete Once Again
The LIV Golf analyst was discussing Joaquin Niemann's current absence from three of the four men's Major championships following the Chilean's win at LIV Golf Mayakoba


LIV Golf analyst Jerry Foltz believes the four men's Major championships are "already on the verge" of having a little metaphorical asterisk next to them as the strongest possible fields are not currently being lined up due to the sport's fractured nature.
Those who crossed over to LIV have taken a hit in their Official World Golf Ranking (OWGR) spot as a result of the measuring body not recognizing the Saudi-backed circuit on its list of eligible tours.
Players like Joaquin Niemann have been affected the most, with the Chilean consistently playing excellent golf since his move in August 2022 but failing to secure spots in three of the four biggest events during 2024 as a result of his drop in the OWGR.
He played all four Majors in 2023, securing a T16 at the Masters and T32 in the US Open but missing the cut in the Open Championship and PGA Championship, respectively.
The 25-year-old has been a stand-out player in an increasingly impressive LIV field, though, and saw off new signing Jon Rahm and 2017 Masters winner, Sergio Garcia to claim the LIV Golf Mayakoba title for Torque GC.
Immediately after the round when speaking to reporter Dom Boulet, Niemann responded to questions about his most recent achievement by consistently bringing the conversation back to what he feels is an injustice involving the Majors.
Joaquin Niemann won $4m but no world ranking points after taking down Sergio Garcia and Jon Rahm in Mexico
Boulet said: "Joaquin, you're one of the best players in the world, we expected you to win earlier..."
Get the Golf Monthly Newsletter
Subscribe to the Golf Monthly newsletter to stay up to date with all the latest tour news, equipment news, reviews, head-to-heads and buyer’s guides from our team of experienced experts.
Niemann: "But I'm not in the Majors."
Boulet: "Maybe you will be. But to win your first event, going head to head with Jon Rahm and beating your mentor, Sergio Garcia in a playoff - how special is this?"
Niemann: "It's freaking awesome. I've been seeing this for the last couple of weeks, and I saw myself on the practice ground putting that last putter to win. It's freaking awesome."
Boulet: "You want to play the Majors - Are you hoping that this win gets the attention of the relevant bodies?"
Niemann: "I hope so, I'm just ready."
Boulet: "Have you set new goals for the rest of the season?"
Niemann: "I want to win Majors, but I've got to get in first!"
Jerry Foltz
In the post-action analysis with host Arlo White, Foltz, and David Feherty, Foltz continued the argument for the Chilean to be teeing it up at Augusta come April at the least.
On Niemann, Foltz said: "He felt like he had a point to prove this week. He is one of the best players in the world, there's not a single person who laces up their golf shoes for a living who doesn't believe he is one of the best players in the world.
"The rankings that don't answer to the organizing bodies that control the political bargaining chip that is the OWGR - they all would have him in the Major championships through legitimate rankings.
"Now, the win at the Australian Open gets him into the Open Championship, but that'd be the only one, and it's really a shame.
"I think the Majors are really close to - if not already on the verge of - becoming asterisk Majors, in my opinion. If they don't do what their institutions have always guaranteed - and that is try to gather the greatest players in the world to compete for the most coveted titles - then I think as long as this political stronghold over the world rankings continues to be allowed to be the barometer by which players are entered into the Majors, I think they become a little bit lessened to the historical significance of those championships.
"But it's not too late. All you'd have to do is create a different category with a fair ranking system and add it to the current system."
Feherty chipped in towards the end of Foltz's monologue to promise fans that Niemann "will be in The Masters" as the tournament is an invitational - an avenue which could rescue the hopes of a few other LIV players as well.
Niemann and his fellow LIV competitors can also qualify for the Open Championship and the US Open outright, should they need to, while some may need to hope for an invite to play at the PGA Championship or The Masters.
Jonny Leighfield is our Staff News Writer who joined Golf Monthly just in time for the 2023 Solheim Cup and Ryder Cup. He graduated from the University of Brighton with a degree in Sport Journalism in 2017 and spent almost five years as the sole sports reporter at his local newspaper. During his time with Golf Monthly, Jonny has interviewed several stars of the game, including Robert MacIntyre, Ian Poulter, Lee Westwood, and Joaquin Niemann. An improving golfer himself, Jonny enjoys learning as much about the game as he can and recently reached his Handicap goal of 18 for the first time. He attended both the 150th and 151st Open Championships and dreams of attending The Masters one day.
-
The 7 Biggest Golf Gear Trends In 2025
Take a look at the most popular golf equipment trends of 2025 and why your game may benefit from them
By Sam De'Ath Published
-
Forget Amazon's Big Spring Sale, Garmin Has These 5 Excellent Deals Worth Your Attention
Amazon isn't the only place for the best golf deals ahead of the new season...
By Conor Keenan Published
-
LIV Golf Unveils Its Own Version Of Creator Classic Featuring Grant Horvat, Rick Shiels, Fat Perez And Bryan Bros
Taking place at LIV Golf Miami, six players from the circuit will play alongside six of the game's biggest content creators in a nine-hole scramble event
By Matt Cradock Published
-
Carlos Ortiz 'Overjoyed' To Earn Open Championship Spot After Pulling Away From LIV Rivals During International Series Macau Victory
The Mexican finished with a blistering six-under 64 to earn his second Asian Tour prize and clinch a spot at the 153rd Open Championship
By Jonny Leighfield Published
-
LIV Golf Leaderboard At International Series Macau - Open Spots Up For Grabs As Multiple LIV Pros In Contention Going Into Final Day
After a busy Moving Day at Macau Golf and Country Club, a number of LIV golfers are in contention for the victory and a potential spot at The Open Championship
By Matt Cradock Last updated
-
'If We Want To Figure Out Why The Game Of Golf Is Not Back Together, Go Ask Those Guys' - Scottie Scheffler Insists LIV Golfers To Blame For Golf's Big Divide
Scottie Scheffler reiterated his stance that LIV golfers were to blame for the continued split in men's pro golf, while insisting the PGA Tour still had a better standard
By Paul Higham Published
-
Paul McGinley Proposes ‘One Of The Things That I Think LIV Have Got Right’ To Be Applied To PGA Tour
The Golf Channel analyst thinks a key change implemented by LIV Golf could make all the difference to the PGA Tour
By Mike Hall Published
-
Joaquin Niemann Wins LIV Golf Singapore Title
The Chilean won his second LIV Golf event of the season thanks to a bogey-free 65 on Sunday in Singapore
By Elliott Heath Published
-
Jon Rahm Equals Bryson DeChambeau's LIV Golf Record After Strong Start In Singapore
The Legion XIII captain matched Bryson DeChambeau's record for consecutive scores under-par in the second round of LIV Golf Singapore
By Mike Hall Published
-
‘I Think It’s Dead, I Think The Other Side Is Gone’ - Lee Trevino Gives Take On PGA Tour-LIV Golf Divide And Calls For Players And Caddies To Speed Up
Lee Trevino was full of praise for the PGA Tour and its immediate future, as he believes that a deal with the Saudi PIF may not come at all
By Paul Higham Published