Cheap Vs Expensive Driver Test: Can Spending Less Pay Off In 2024?
Driver tester Joe Ferguson takes a look at what - if anything - you are compromising on by entering the ‘budget’ driver market in this cheap vs expensive driver test…
![Cheap Vs Expensive Driver Test: Can Spending Less Pay Off In 2024?](https://cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.net/sAHntBwZSd9Zpn4mVVXpS5-415-80.jpg)
In the current somewhat unstable economic times, it is imperative that you are getting value for your money, and that particularly applies to golf equipment. But if you are going down the route of the best budget golf drivers, do you really know what you are missing out on, or are you missing out at all? I took a look at two drivers very much at opposing ends of the price spectrum in 2024, the Ping G430 Max 10K (RRP £599) and the MacGregror V-Max (RRP £129.99) to try and clear things up…
WATCH: Joe Ferguson puts two very differently priced new drivers to the test
Looks
We all know that the aesthetic of our golf clubs is important to us in terms of inspiring confidence and a feeling of quality, and nowhere is that more important than with the best drivers. It would probably be fair to say that the drivers featured here would be on the fussier end of the looks scale, with both having quite a lot to occupy the eye when down in the playing position.
Firstly the Ping G430 Max 10K has a very stretched out profile in comparison to the MacGregor driver, but that is the case with the Ping versus most drivers on the market. Ping squashed the head down vertically to facilitate a larger overall footprint which is very evident when put alongside its cheaper counterpart.
The Carbonfly wrap crown gives the Max 10K a really premium look, whereas the simpler matt finish of the MacGregor driver doesn’t give off quite the same vibe. There is also a lot of interesting topography on the crown of the Ping driver to help with the aerodynamics such as the turbulators, whereas once again the V-Max is a touch more basic in design contouring.
On the sole, once again the Ping product is a touch more sophisticated with sharper lines and branding, and the MacGregor V-Max may lack a little attention to detail in terms of the paintwork which has spilled over in places. That said, the overall look of the V-Max is pretty strong and certainly from a looks point of view a more than 400% price difference cannot be fully justified in this department at least.
Features
I think it is fair to say that this is where the Ping driver begins to put its foot down and separate itself from its less expensive opponent. The G430 Max 10K is absolutely packed with tech features. Along with the aforementioned larger footprint, Ping has added a heavy fixed back weight for increased MOI, the Carbonfly wrap crown to save and redistribute weight, and very importantly, an adjustable loft sleeve that allows players to customize the loft and lie settings to their liking. All of these features make the Max 10K one of the best drivers for high handicappers.
Get the Golf Monthly Newsletter
Subscribe to the Golf Monthly newsletter to stay up to date with all the latest tour news, equipment news, reviews, head-to-heads and buyer’s guides from our team of experienced experts.
It is a slightly different story with the MacGregor driver with the only tangible technology referred to on the website being the 460cc all titanium head. Aside from that, we see a couple of mentions of ultra-slim face and oversized sweet-spot without really giving any details or measurements of how this is achieved, so once again slightly more basic in this regard.
However, the features and technology are only impressive if they work, so how did each driver perform?
Performance
Firstly, in terms of the unquantifiable performance elements such as sound and feel, there was quite a bit of difference between the two models. The MacGregor driver was significantly more high-pitched and louder than the Ping model, which is interesting as the Max 10K is generally considered one of the noisier of the premium drivers. The feel of the V-Max was solid, if a little harsh at impact, but overall not unpleasant at all. The Ping G430 Max 10K presented a slightly duller, ‘thuddier’ impact sensation.
As for the launch monitor data I gathered on my Full Swing KIT launch monitor, the gap in performance began to become apparent.
The MacGregor driver launched a touch higher and certainly produced more spin than the Max 10k, but it was a bit excessive for me. Over 3500 rpm is too high certainly for me and this, along with a fairly modest ball speed output of 165mph from 116mph of clubhead speed resulted in a pretty conservative carry number of 263 yards. What I will say however is that the shaft in the Ping driver was much more suited to me and due to the additional spin, I found the ball flight very stable and dispersion was extremely tight with the Macgregor.
Onto the Ping, and the numbers were a lot more in line with what I am used to seeing. An average carry number of 285 yards was over 20 yards further than the V-Max and this came from around 5mph more ball speed and a significantly reduced spin number of around 2450rpm, all from a similar clubhead speed input.
Verdict
Now this wasn’t a fair fight from the start. I don’t even think MacGregor would have suggested that the V-Max would keep pace with the G430 Max 10K, but that wasn’t really what this exercise was about. I wanted to see if the difference in price of over 400% was reflected in the overall difference between these two drivers, and the answer was probably no.
Whilst there was a fairly significant difference in every category of looks, features, and performance, I wouldn’t say that in any category the Ping driver was more than 4 times better to warrant the price discrepancy. As such, it would be fair to say that if you are someone looking for a solid option, and can make peace with the fact that optimal performance is maybe out of your price range, then there are clubs out there that punch above their weight, and the MacGregor V-Max driver is certainly one of them for £129.99.
Joe has worked in the golf industry for nearly 20 years in a variety of roles. After a successful amateur career being involved in England squads at every age group, Joe completed his PGA degree qualification in 2014 as one of the top ten graduates in his training year and subsequently went on to become Head PGA Professional at Ryder Cup venue The Celtic Manor Resort. Equipment has always been a huge passion of Joe’s, and during his time at Celtic Manor, he headed up the National Fitting Centres for both Titleist and Taylormade. He’s excited to bring his knowledge of hardware to Golf Monthly in the form of equipment reviews and buying advice.
Joe lives in North Devon and still plays sporadically on the PGA West region circuit. His best round in recent years came earlier in 2023 where he managed a 9 under par 63 at Trevose GC in a Devon & Cornwall PGA Tournament.
Joe's current What's In The Bag?
Driver: Switch between Ping G430 Max 10K & TaylorMade Qi10 - both with Fujikura Ventus Black 6-X
Fairway wood: TaylorMade Qi10 Tour - Fujikura Ventus Black 7-X
Irons: Callaway Apex CB 24' 3-11 - Project X LS 6.5 shafts
Wedges: Titleist Vokey SM10 54D and 60M
Putter: Odyssey Toe Up #9
Ball: TaylorMade 2024 TP5x
Grips: Golf Pride Tour Velvet 60R
Bag: Vessel Player IV Pro DXR Stand
-
R&A Plans To Use Same Courses On Both Open Rotas With 'One Exception' For Women's Championship
Martin Slumbers said that both the men's and women's Open Championship will move towards being played at the same courses - but "with one exception" for the AIG Women's Open
By Jonny Leighfield Published
-
Revealed: The Mind-Blowing Difference In PGA Tour Prize Pools From 1994 To 2024
Season-long prize pools on the PGA Tour have increased dramatically over the last 30 years, as this comparison with the 1994 golfing season demonstrates
By Nick Bonfield Published
-
Taking On An Open Championship Course With Only A Bag Of Irons!
Staff writer and PGA Pro Joe Ferguson took on YouTuber Matt Fryer in a match around Royal Liverpool GC but with a twist…
By Golf Monthly Published
-
My 6 Biggest Equipment Takeaways From Attending A LIV Golf Event
I recently attended the LIV Golf UK event and was really surprised by some of the equipment I saw. Here's what stood out...
By Joe Ferguson Published
-
Does This Vintage Iron Set From 1994 Offer The Best Value For Money?
In the latest Retro Review, Joe Ferguson tests out the 1994 Callaway Big Bertha irons to see how they perform and stack up in today's power world
By Joe Ferguson Published
-
We've Tested Everything... These Are The 10 Best Golf Gadgets For Under $100 Right Now
We break down the best affordable golf gadgets to help you improve your game and enjoy your rounds more for under $100
By Sam De'Ath Published
-
Maximize Your Power With Matt Fryer
PGA Professional and Fujikura ambassador Matt Fryer offers some advice on how to hit longer drives…
By Joe Ferguson Published
-
How A Shaft Fitting Can Transform Your Driving
Equipment expert Joe Ferguson takes a deeper look at the importance of being fitted into the correct driver shaft…
By Joe Ferguson Published
-
7 Handicap Player Gains 30 Yards With This Lesson!
PGA Professional and Fujikura ambassador Matt Fryer makes some incredible distance gains with a club golfer…
By Joe Ferguson Published
-
We Did Not Expect That! Exciting New Gear Spotted At The Wyndham Championship
We dive into some of the new and most unique gear ahead of the Wyndham Championship this week on the PGA Tour
By Sam De'Ath Published