Will 18-Hole Golf Become A Thing Of The Past? - Why More Players And Golf Clubs Want Shorter Formats
Top 50 coach Katie Dawkins investigates why golfers and golf clubs are attracted to shorter formats
![9 hole in a buggy takes less than 2 hours](https://cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.net/jxpLQSEmFZBABxFUrNXK56-415-80.jpg)
For years I have regularly enjoyed playing less than 18 holes. Not necessarily by choice, but through circumstances. I’m a mum, I work full time, I’m self-employed and I cannot give the time for 18 unless it’s a special occasion. I know for a fact that I am not alone in this. According to 2023 research carried out by experience platform Players 1st, 52% of golfers are interested in booking 6,9 or even 12 hole rounds given the choice.
I’ve had time to accept that this is my golf (for now) and I actually really enjoy 9 holes, possibly more than I did 18. Not simply because of the time factor, but I find myself relaxing enough to enjoy it more.
In the past when faced with a whole day out of my schedule, I’d enter the event already stressing about work and how I would make the time up. This takes away from the experience. With 9 holes I know I have made time and it’s not eaten into my day to have a serious impact.
Nine holes is scoffed at by many a stalwart 18-hole golfer. But it doesn’t mean you have to forgo competitions or the ability to gain a handicap, as 9 holes can be a competitive format and should be widely available at all courses.
It’s not just women, there are plenty of men who would benefit from a shorter version. Whether it’s time or health orientated issues holding them back, a 20:20 cricket version of golf may just get them dusting off their clubs or taking up the sport from scratch, but for this piece, I want to shine the spotlight on women.
Being a 9 hole member is appealing to busy women
I recently gave a talk to a group of women who play at a prestigious club and they all have a golf handicap. They regularly play 18 holes and rarely without a scorecard. I asked them how many would embrace a 9 hole format of the game, akin to 9 hole leagues and matches played at many golf clubs in the USA and Canada.
Some of the women literally melted, saying that it would be amazing. Many admitted to squeezing in golf around an already busy diary filled with grandparent duties and other hobbies. Some also confessed to totally losing concentration after 12 holes as they just had too many other things to think about. This lease of focus can be sorted with a nifty pre-shot routine, but at the end of the day, some of these golfers are out there playing the kind of game they think they should be playing, not the game they’d love to be playing. I guarantee if you asked members of ladies’ sections at clubs all over the world, there would be a demand for a shorter version of golf.
Get the Golf Monthly Newsletter
Subscribe to the Golf Monthly newsletter to stay up to date with all the latest tour news, equipment news, reviews, head-to-heads and buyer’s guides from our team of experienced experts.
Golf has always struggled to retain female players, traditionally losing them as teens or as they become mothers. The time golf takes is a huge barrier to women with little or no time to themselves. Add to that the distinct lack of creche facilities at golf clubs, it’s no wonder we see so few young mothers playing golf. Walk into a David Lloyd or other leisure facility and it’s a different story, providing childcare so women can take part in their chosen activities. If golf clubs adopted the same approach I believe we’d see a huge rise in mothers taking up the sport.
If golf was readily available as 3, 6 or 9 holes you’d immediately see mothers joined by grandmothers, students and businesswomen, especially if the benefits of golf within the workplace were shouted about more.
The 9 hole Channel Course at Burnham & Berrow Golf Club
The environmental benefits of having a 9 hole course are staggering. As a new development, far less land is required and there’s far less impact on the natural biome. From a sustainability point of view it makes a lot of sense cost wise and environmentally to have either shorter courses or fewer holes. Clubs don’t need to start bulldozing their back nine, but some courses might want to consider the benefits of pushing 9 hole green fees.
However, I do know a few courses who are considering reducing 18 holes to 12 or 9, not just from a sustainability perspective, but because of the demand for a faster and more bite-sized version of the game. If golfers are playing smaller versions, they’ll play more often.
Golfers would tee up multiple times in a week, increasing the spin of sales in food, drink and hire at their club.
According to the aforementioned Players 1st research, “Golfers would play 35% more often and they’d feel they are getting their money’s worth for their membership.”
Multiple visits in the week means multiple food and beverage purchases and increased revenue in other spins of sales. Clubs can fill those quieter gaps with shorter round green fees as special offers. Of course, 18 holes of golf will always be the pinnacle of the sport, but making a shorter and more manageable version of the game is critical if the sport is to grow.
There are swathes of people who won’t even consider playing golf until this option of a shorter version is explained and not ridiculed. If clubs aren’t willing to accommodate a 9 hole round then they’re going to miss out, which leaves the door wide open to new ventures who are thinking way outside the box.
More young people would play a shorter version golf
A golf course that is willing to convert their current 18 to just 9 and then develop the rest of the site with leisure facilities and impressive practice facilities that incorporate some of the old holes, including a 3-6 hole pitch and putt course, perhaps some crazy golf, as well as short-game area. A facility to really hone your game and improve as well as encouraging beginners, juniors and women. It will accommodate lots of parking, and boast a clubhouse fit for family friendly functions and special occasions - my perfect club would have all these features.
The future of golf clubs lies with facilities that want to change up their customer base and become engulfed with families and young people, as well as those seeking somewhere to do business and play with clients without taking the entire working day up.
It doesn’t matter how many clubs do schemes or free taster days for juniors, women and new golfers, if there isn’t a shorter version of golf available to them as part of their pathway into the sport and the club, then the majority don’t pursue the game.
Life is busy, but 9 holes in a buggy followed by lunch ticks a box for many women
Golf isn’t something that fits into the majority of women’s lives under the age of 50. Life is busy. Present the chance to play 5 holes on a pitch and putt alongside the kids with fun competitions and dinosaurs, then the option for an hour’s fun session followed by spa - now you’re talking. This will attract a huge percentage of people who would simply never have given the traditional format of 18 holes of golf a chance.
Katie is an Advanced PGA professional with over 20 years of coaching experience. She helps golfers of every age and ability to be the best versions of themselves. In January 2022 she was named as one of Golf Monthly's Top 50 Coaches.
Katie coaches the individual and uses her vast experience in technique, psychology and golf fitness to fix problems in a logical manner that is effective - she makes golf simple. Katie is now based on the edge of the New Forest. An experienced club coach, she developed GardenGOLF during lockdown and as well as coaching at Iford Golf Centre, The Caversham- Home of Reading Golf Club and Hamptworth Golf Club she freelances, operating via pop-up clinics and travelling to clients homes to help them use their space to improve.
She has coached tour pros on both LET tour and the Challenge Tour as well as introduced many a beginner to the game.
Katie has been writing instructional content for magazines for 20 years. Her creative approach to writing is fuelled by her sideline as an artist.
Katie's Current What's In The Bag
Driver: TaylorMade Qi10 9degrees.
Fairway: TaylorMade Qi10 5wood
Hybrid: TaylorMade 4 & 5
Irons: TaylorMade 770 6-AW
Wedges: TaylorMade Tour Grind 4 54 & 58
Putter: TaylorMade Tour X 33"
Favourite Shoes: FootJoy HyperFlex with Tour Flex Pro Softspikes on the course.
-
Former PGA Tour Pro Opens Up On Battles With Alcoholism
Steve Wheatcroft has opened up on his issues, which came to the surface in 2019, three years after he retired from the game
By Mike Hall Published
-
Report: PGA Tour's McIlroy And Scheffler To Face LIV Golf's DeChambeau And Koepka In TV Match
A report from Eamon Lynch at Golfweek states that the four stars are set to appear in a made-for-TV contest to be held in Las Vegas in mid-December
By Mike Hall Published
-
'I Picked Up 3 Tips From Watching The World No.1 Amateur Golfer'
After watching Lottie Woad at the Curtis Cup, single-figure golfer Jess Ratcliffe offers 3 tips that will help to improve your game
By Jess Ratcliffe Published
-
5 Things You Need To Know About The Curtis Cup
Playing in the Curtis Cup is arguably the pinnacle of any woman’s amateur career. Here's what you need to know about this prestigious team event
By Carly Frost Published
-
Forgotten The Basics? Get Your Game Back On Track Quickly With These 5 Tips (Inspired By Lydia Ko)
When you're out on the golf course it's easy to rush and forget the basics, so here are 5 strategy and set-up tips
By Jess Ratcliffe Published
-
'On TV, It Felt Slow And Somewhat Tedious' – Why We Cannot Let Slow Play Impact Golf’s Entertainment Value
Professional golf needs to speed up to generate and retain interest from existing and new audiences
By Alison Root Published
-
Did The AIG Women's Open Signal A Wind Of Change For Women's Golf?
Carly Frost reflects on the AIG Women's Open. Here are her key takeaways from the final women's Major of the season
By Carly Frost Published
-
An In-Depth Preview To The AIG Women's Open, The Major Everyone Wants To Win....
Who will lift the coveted AIG Women's Open trophy? Reflection and predictions for the final women's Major of the year
By Alison Root Published
-
New adidas x JAY3LLE Collection Infuses Energy Into Women’s Golf Fashion
adidas and JAY3LLE have come together to create new bold and dynamic golf apparel for women
By Alison Root Published
-
7 Ways Golf Clubs Can (And Should) Be More Welcoming To Juniors
Here's PGA Professional Emma Booth's advice for golf clubs on the best ways to make junior golfers feel more welcome
By Emma Booth Published