I Followed Scheffler And McIlroy On Masters Friday, The Gulf In Class Couldn't Have Been Clearer
While the ten shot difference tells one story, watching them side by side gave me a deeper insight into why Rory is so far off it


Following world number one Scottie Scheffler and Rory McIlroy yesterday was the clearest evidence I've seen of just how far off it Rory is right now. A 10 shot gap after two rounds should be evidence enough of the gulf between them, but watching them side by side in the exact same conditions showed me the gulf is probably even bigger than the leaderboard suggests.
Scheffler is in a world of his own right now. He's got the look of a man who is just out to play golf as opposed to thinking about swinging a golf club. Minimal swing thoughts, executing whatever shot is in front of him at any one time. He might be one of the more docile characters on tour and on the course he has the air of a man who's life exists outside of golf.
Rory on the other hand looks like a man battling voices in his head, a million different swing thoughts and a desperation to play well again. After his 77 yesterday he told the media, 'My golf swing felt horrific for the last six or seven holes.' It looked like it too. It all went wrong on 11, where a double bogey pushed him closer to the cut line and his golf became tight and tetchy.
Rory produced no birdies yesterday. Over the first two days he hit a miserable 17/36 greens in regulation compared to Scheffler's 23/36, both of whom are behind Max Homa's and Bryson DeChambeau's 26 greens in regulation. Rory's driving stats - just 6/14 fairways found yesterday - was tied for 86th in an 89 man field. When Rory's driver isn't firing, you know his swing really isn't in good shape.
He bemoaned the pace of play on the 11th in particular. 'It felt like it took an hour to play that hole. It was stop and start, hard to get into a rhythm with the conditions and obviously how slow the play was as well.' It feels like this kinds of external criticisms that only come from a player not swinging it at their best.
Shaking hands at the end of their first round
Scheffler - who's biggest error of the day came when he played the 5th-7th holes in two over par - acknowledged the slow pace of play, but emphasized how he refuses to let that bother him.
'I try to relax as much as possible out there, but I feel like I teed off 10 hours ago. It was a long day. And, I mean, that's what happens. When you have greens this fast and this much wind and that much water out there, it's going to take a while to play golf. That's pretty much it.'
Get the Golf Monthly Newsletter
Subscribe to the Golf Monthly newsletter to stay up to date with all the latest tour news, equipment news, reviews, head-to-heads and buyer’s guides from our team of experienced experts.
I could see Scheffler visibly switch off while he was waiting. He's got a calm, distant stare and the aura of a man who is in no rush. With all that's going on in his life - his pregnant wife is due to give birth in the next two weeks - how he keeps himself so calm and focused is beyond me. Yes he's got one of the best swings and short games on tour, but watching him stroll around the course led me to believe he's got one of the best attitudes towards the game too. All this is probably quite easy when you're the best players in the world.
Rory on the other hand looked restless, eager to fire in a close iron shot or a big drive to get something, anything going. Missed greens or putts that slid by were greeted by confused stares and frustrated looks. Every good shot was quickly followed by an indifferent one.
Scheffler's demeanor never changes, good shot or bad. Bad shots were followed up by sensible ones and the fact he bogeyed the 5th and 7th was incredibly uncharacteristic of a man who has one of the best bogey bounce back percentages on tour.
One thing I can't deny about both players is how much they both work on their swing. Both were seen hitting balls in the darkness on the range, so there's no gulf between the players' drive and want to get better.
When I first saw the groups drawn I feared for Rory. A player who has been - and still can be - so good to have to watch the best player in the world run rings around him can't have been easy. Out in a two ball today with Camilo Villegas, I suspected he'll prefer the lower profile company. It's become an ongoing joke that Rory loves a back door top 10 or top five at majors, but that's looking a long way from a possibility this year.

Dan has been with Golf Monthly team since 2021. He graduated with a Masters degree in International Journalism from the University of Sussex and looks after equipment reviews and buying guides, specializing in golf shoe, golf bag, golf cart and apparel reviews. Dan has now tested and reviewed over 30 pairs of golf shoes and is an expert in the field. A left-handed golfer, his handicap index is currently 6.5 and he plays at Fulford Heath Golf Club in the West Midlands.
Dan's current clubs:
Driver: Ping G440 Max 9°
Fairway: Ping G440 Max 15°, Ping G425 Max 20.5°
Irons: Cobra King Tec Utility, Ping i230 (5-PW)
Wedges: Ping Glide Forged Pro
Putter: TaylorMade Spider Tour X
Ball: Titleist Pro V1
-
Rory McIlroy Explains His Extraordinary Pre-Round Routine (And It's The Complete Opposite Of Most Amateurs)
McIlroy shares what goes into his usual pre-round routine at tournaments and what his timetable looks like before arriving at the first tee
By Jonny Leighfield Published
-
‘You Kinda Did It To Yourself’ – When Bryson DeChambeau Needled Rory McIlroy Over US Open Battle
Months after Bryson DeChambeau’s defeat of Rory McIlroy in the US Open, the two met in Las Vegas, where the LIV Golfer had a lightning-quick response to a humorous comment from his rival
By Mike Hall Published
-
If Bryson DeChambeau Wins The Masters Today, Will He Eclipse Scottie Scheffler As Golf's Shining Star?
Bryson DeChambeau heads into the final round at The Masters with a chance to win a third Major, which I believe would firmly cement him as golf's new poster boy
By Barry Plummer Published
-
Dear Masters Tournament Committee: Please Change The Final-Round Pin Positions On 16 And 18
The back nine at Augusta National on Masters Sunday is scintillating, but I’ve been campaigning for different pin positions on 16 and 18 for years...
By Nick Bonfield Published
-
Would A Rory McIlroy Implosion At The Masters Be His Worst Defeat Ever?
Rory McIlroy stormed into the lead with a record breaking front nine on Saturday at Augusta National, but his turbulence in Major Championships makes me nervous
By Barry Plummer Published
-
Does Television Commentary Improve The Masters Viewing Experience? I Can Name 5 Different Ways I'd Rather Immerse Myself In The Action
Watching The Masters on TV is an annual tradition for many golfers, but does the commentary improve the experience? I can think of five better alternatives...
By Barry Plummer Published
-
I Asked AI To Predict The Top-10 Finishers At The Masters...
AI has already helped me to pick the outright winner of The Masters, so I decided to task it with finding some top-10 finish picks in time for the weekend...
By Barry Plummer Published
-
'The Masters Is Getting To A Point Where It's Turning Off New Golf Fans' – Viewers Express Irritation At Lack Of Bryson DeChambeau Coverage
Bryson DeChambeau is a blockbuster name in world golf, but viewers saw very little of his surging second round at The Masters... and they were not very happy!
By Barry Plummer Published
-
Can I Watch The Masters For Free?
Here's how you can watch the action from Augusta National for free this weekend, with details on free streaming at Masters.com and broadcaster free trials.
By Patrick Fletcher Published
-
I Am So Fed Up With The Masters Television Coverage... Why Can't We Watch A Full Day's Play?
The strict television rules around The Masters at Augusta National are really starting to bug me, especially in this modern era of mass sports consumption...
By Barry Plummer Published